The Magician of Tiger Castle — Book Review with Content Warnings

Author: Louis Sachar

Genre: Fantasy adventure

Series: Standalone

Age Rating: Teen+

Synopsis

Anatole is a magician nearing disgrace… until he is offered a way to increase his standing again by making a forgetting potion for the princess Tullia so that she forgets her true love and agrees to an arranged marriage. Will he save the kingdom and his own reputation by betraying the princess? Or will he risk ruin?

Content Warnings

General Rating: Teen+ (14A / PG-13 / TV-MA)

• Spice Rating: None

• Violence Rating: Mild

• Profanity Rating: None

• Other Trigger Warnings: murder, animal death

Overall Rating: 4/5

A sharp, witty, fantastic adventure with Anatole, the king’s eccentric and disgraced magician. This is Louis Sachar’s first adult fantasy—don’t be fooled, this one is nothing like Holes, but is still an enjoyable adventure!

What I Liked

• Eccentric protagonist: Anatole has his quirks; for one, he can’t grow any hair on his body. At all. A symptom of a potion gone sideways. He thinks highly of himself and is desperate to increase his standing with the king, but he also loves Tullia as a father loves his daughter, so the tension is palpable.

• Unreliable narrator: Anatole isn’t the most reliable narrator; for all his supposed genius, he misses what goes on right underneath his nose.

What I Didn’t Like

• Lack of depth: It’s a fantasy adventure, and I thought that certain themes or events were going to delve deeper than they did… but they didn’t. Sachar seems happy to leave the book as a grand adventure rather than exploring deeper themes.

Themes and Reflections

• Unreliable narration: It’s always interesting when an author chooses an unreliable narrator. The reader is frequently left puzzling together Anatole’s words and reports, trying to decipher whether this is truly how events unfolded or if this is simply Anatole’s bias.

“In 1523 kings and queens didn’t concern themselves about the humane treatment of animals. To be fair, they weren’t overly concerned about the humane treatment of humans, either. ”

— The Magician of Tiger Castle, Louis Sachar

Writing Style

• Witty, enigmatic, and humorous prose

• Fragmented and episodic pacing with time jumps and editorial comments

• Enchanting and whimsical tone

• One-dimensional characterization, but endearing and sympathetic

• Sharp, snappy dialogue

• Derivative, detailed worldbuilding

• First-person POV
  

Tropes

• Court intrigue

• The unlikely hero

• Quest
  

Books Like This

• The Princess Bride by William Goldman

• Howl’s Moving Castle by Diana Wynne Jones

• Spinning Silver by Naomi Novik

Publisher Info

• Publisher: Ace

• Release Date: August 5, 2025

---

See More Reviews

For more in-depth reviews of theological themes and reflections…