Fantasy, fiction, and honest reviews with content clarity
All opinions are my own and are therefore subjective. Book reviews are intended to provide a synopsis, content warnings, and brief overview of themes so that readers may consume wisely.
Among the Burning Flowers— Book Review with Content Warnings
Book review with content and trigger warnings for Among the Burning Flowers by Samantha Shannon
Assassin’s Apprentice— Book Review with Content Warnings
Book review with content and trigger warnings for Assassin’s Apprentice by Robin Hobb
Fallen City — Book Review with Content Warnings
Book review with content and trigger warnings for Fallen City by Adrienne Young
Hemlock & Silver — Book Review with Content Warnings
Book review with content and trigger warnings for Hemlock & Silver by T. Kingfisher
Spinning Silver — Book Review with Content Warnings
Book review with content and trigger warnings for Spinning Silver by Naomi Novik
The Golem and the Jinni — Book Review with Content Warnings
Book review with content and trigger warnings for The Golem and the Jinni by Helene Wecker
Swordheart — Book Review with Content Warnings
Book review with content and trigger warnings for Swordheart by T. Kingfisher
The Ten Thousand Doors of January — Book Review with Content Warnings
Book review with content and trigger warnings for The Ten Thousand Doors of January by Alix E. Harrow
Silvercloak — Book Review with Content Warnings
Book review with content and trigger warnings for Silvercloak by L.K. Steven
Nettle & Bone — Book Review with Content Warnings
Book review with content and trigger warnings for Nettle and Bone by T. Kingfisher
The Once and Future Witches — Book Review with Content Warnings
Book review with content and trigger warnings for The Once and Future Witches by Alix E. Harrow
Katabasis — Book Review with Content Warnings
Book review with content and trigger warnings for Katabasis by R.F. Kuang
A Harvest of Hearts — Book Review and Content Warnings
Book review with content and trigger warnings for A Harvest of Hearts by Andrea Eames
Wild Reverence by Rebecca Ross — Review and Content Warnings
Book review with content and trigger warnings for Wild Reverence by Rebecca Ross
The Darkest Oath by Lauren Lee Merewether — Review and Content Warnings
A historical fantasy set in the French Revolution - a knight who is cursed to live for eternity without love, a woman who has only known abuse, and the tinderbox of 18th century Paris
The Knight and the Moth by Rachel Gillig — Review and Content Warnings
A romantic Gothic fantasy about a prophetess, a knight, and a gargoyle who search for the truth to overthrow a corrupt system
‘Heartless Hunter’ by Kristen Ciccarelli
A dark YA fantasy about witch hunts, magic, and enemies who fall in love
‘One Dark Window’ by Rachel Gillig
A light gothic new adult fantasy novel exploring themes of truth, identity, and self-sacrifice
‘A Most Puzzling Murder’ by Bianca Marais
An interactive, choose-your-own-adventure fantasy murder mystery novel set on spooky Eerie Island
Rating Guide
All ratings are subjective, as it is impossible to objectively rate content or enjoyability. However, here is a guide to help you understand the content ratings at Enchanted Quill.
Content Warning Guide
Overall age ratings are adjusted for the highest category
Adult: 18+ / R / TV-MA
Spice: Severe — Explicit, detailed on-page sex scenes
Fourth Wing, Game of Thrones
Violence: Severe — Graphic violence, includes abuse
Games of Thrones
Profanity: Severe — Heavy profanity, including slurs (”f*ck,” “motherf*ker,” graphic/crude terms)
Fourth Wing
Teen+: 14+ / 14A / TV-14
Moderate content; may not be suitable for younger teens. May include complex or controversial texts, moral ambiguity, and nuance. Ages 15-16+, Gr. 10-12.
Spice: Moderate — On-page sex, mildly described or non-explicit; no graphic details
The Handmaid’s Tale (Gr. 11-12)
Violence: Moderate — On-page violence, death, or injury, mentions or moderate depictions of abuse, realistic violence
Lord of the Flies, Of Mice and Men (Gr. 10-12)
Profanity: Moderate — Frequent mid-level swearing (”sh*t,” “bastard,” “damn,” “hell”)
Catcher in the Rye (Gr. 10-12)
Family Friendly/Clean: 10+ / PG / TV-PG
Light content suitable for most readers. Ages 10-14, Gr. 5-9.
Spice: Mild — Kissing, implied intimacy, no innuendo
Anne of Green Gables (Gr. 5-8)
Violence: Mild — Off-page or light action, mild peril or danger
Holes, The Outsiders (Gr. 6-9)
Profanity: Mild — Occasional mild swears (”crap,” “heck,” “dang”)
The Outsiders (Gr. 6-9)
Archives by Genre
- Alternate fairytale
- Alternate history
- Book reviews
- Classic Fantasy
- Contemporary fantasy
- Contemporary literature
- Cozy fantasy
- Dark Fantasy
- Epic Fantasy
- Fairytale retelling
- Fantasy
- Fantasy Romance
- Feminist Fantasy
- Gothic Fantasy
- Historical Fantasy
- Literary Fantasy
- Military Fantasy
- Murder mystery
- Mythic Fantasy
- Paranormal Fantasy
- Political Fantasy
- Romantasy book reviews
- Sapphic romance
- Satire
- Teen Fantasy
- Whimsical fantasy
- YA Fantasy